Shepherdstown visited by “Rowdies”
November 14, 2026Riots on the Washington Railroad
November 14, 2026Mr. Editor:– In your last issue appears an editorial condemnatory of a transaction in which I, with several other young men took a decidedly prominent part; and as your columns contained the censure, it is but right that through the same medium our answer should be made, and therefore to you I address myself, requesting the publication of this article.
You have stated that on the night of Monday June 28th, a portion of our citizens, rode on a rail and ducked in the “Mill-Pond”–“a stranger, for the mere shadow of a fault, committed under the influence of excessive indulgence in “Mint Juleps”– which for aught you know, “may have influenced some of the proceedings of the evening.” Now I wish to tell this community what this poor unfortunate, much-to-be-pittied ‘stranger’ did to merit this treatment, and let them understand what is your idea of the “mere shadow of a fault.”
I believe it was on Friday, the 25th, that the “victim” came to town, giving his name as Matthews, and announcing at the supper-table of the Hotel that he was “a gentleman from Pennsylvania,” with such low-bred familiarity to the waiters, as to make most the ladies leave the table. He professed to sell “polishing powder” for cleaning silver, &c., and under this pretext, instead of going to the front-doors of people’s houses and trying to sell to the master or mistress,– he visited every kitchen and negro quarter in town, as he himself asserted, and on Saturday night was harranguing the slaves on the street-corners, upon the subject of Freedom. This he acknowledged himself, to me, and gave as an excuse, that he was drunk. Is that any palliation; does the Law excuse a crime committed “under the influence of excessive indulgence in Mint-Juleps?” But that he was here for mischief and nothing else is evident from the fact that he made no money and made no exertion to make any; and when driven off (without a chance to decamp) his trunk was retained for his hotel-bill. It is rather unusual for gentlemen to travel and live in the best manner without money and no way of making any, when their mentions are honest or for good. Such conduct got him the “introduction to the Mill-Pond, without the ceremony of undressing;” do you think, now, that he committed the “shadow of a fault?” or is this what you consider such?
Next, Mr. Editor, about the Mint-Julep influence. On Monday morning, Mr. V. Marmaduke and myself arranged the affair and agreed to obtain the assistance of some dozen young men, so that we could be independent of the chance aid of a crowd. Those who, with us, took the foremost part, were Messrs. J. DuShane, A. B. Cameron, M. L. Entler, C. O. Lambert, Alexander Shaner and W. H. Staley: of course there was a crowd beside, but whether they had been drinking or not, I neither know nor care; they knew nothing of the matter until they saw Mr. Matthews conspicuously seated on the rail by our party. The whole matter was arranged long before night; does it look like it was the result of momentary excitement from liquor? Was it an undertaking of such difficulty and danger, that we need fortify our courage with whiskey? As far as some of us are concerned, you know, and so does this community, that liquor had nothing to do with it.
We did thus because our judgment told us, and our indignation prompted us to punish, as we always will, such impertinent interference with our affairs, oy a rascally vagabond like this man. Its all very well to talk about letting the Law protect &c. What would have been the probably result? A fine that he couldn’t pay, or a day or two in the “jug” or an order to leave town, with no punishment. Oh, my! what a severe lesson it would have been to him and his kind to have taken him before a magistrate. Naughty boys: what ta pity you didn’t! No, Sir, there are times when an exasperated community ought to take the summary punishment of a scoundrel into their own hands, and this time it was done “promptly,” if not so desperately “orderly.” Why didn’t some of the opponents of “Mob Law,” present the man for his conduct. Every ni***r in the County might have run off before they’d have moved a finger, and this fellow would have gone unpunished, if we had not taken charge of him. No, Mr. Editor I can tell you that your editorial has been far more condemned and “disapprobated” than our conduct. I have heard everybody in town and country, officers of the Law, ministers, and people, say we did perfectly right, many insisting that he ought to have been tarred and feathered, (and so I think;) and I have not heard one approve your article. I can not understand how you, a Southern editor, in a Southern town, can so speak through your paper, when not six weeks ago, two slaves ran off from town, and in the paper condemning us, you record the stampede of twelve from Loudoun. Are we to submit to have our property quietly argued into leaving us in such gangs? I spoke of our design to Dr. V. M. Butler, on Monday morning, and he told me by all means to go ahead– that if he was in town he’d help. Is he one of the “better portion of our law-abiding citizens,” or not? I can give a list as long as my arm of the most respectable citizens who sustain us, if necessary, and not one who sustains the “Register.” I will notice one other sentence and close an article I did not intend to make ha[?]t so long.
You say, “we have no personal spleen to vent towards any one engaged in the disgraceful affair, nor any apology to offer on behalf of the victim.” This presents a palpable contradiction: You have excused the much-abused “victim” (poor fellow!) by saying he committed “the mere shadow of a fault,” when intoxicated, and yet have no “apology” to offer for him! But further: if the affair was “disgraceful” and wrong, why did you, Mr. Editor, countenance it by your presence and never say one word to show that you “disapprobated” it? If there was any disgrace about it, did you not share it as much as we? I rather think Mr. Editor, that boot is on the wrong leg!
Finally, I wish to say distinctly, that I was the prime mover of this exercise of the “prerogative of Judge Lynch,” and as Doesticks says, “if I’ve done anything I ought to be sorry for, I’m glad of it,” at any rate I’m glad of the part I took; and to you Mr. Editor, and our citizens, I make a faithful promise to tar and feather the next abolitionist who attempts to interfere with our slaves, if I can get two men to help me, and with the same assistance, to hang the third offender. As for those who disapprove this recent affair, let them disapprove till they are tired. We will all, notwithstanding the mortifying knowledge of their objections to such “proceedings,” continue to act with the most utter disregard thereto, and on such occasions, in such a cause– with a polite bow of deference to the “Register” of July 3d– will always be found, beyond any doubt, similarly “riotous.”
EDWIN G. LEE
Bedford, July 6th, 1858
We use this timeline to help us understand the events that may have affected or shaped a person's life. Here are some ideas as to how this timeline may help your further your own research: